Ds Scholarship

Students in Israel Don’t Carry Guns to Class, Contrary to Social Media Posts

Quick Take

Israel has established strict measures in response to armed attacks on its schoolchildren. But social media posts falsely claim there have been “no school shootings in Israel” and use a photo to misleadingly suggest students carry weapons to class. Only guards and other specific personnel — not students — can carry arms in Israeli schools.


Full Story

A mass shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas on May 24 was the deadliest at a US school in a decade, and has once again sparked debate about gun laws and how to protect children in the classroom.

Legislators, educators and others are proposing a variety of measures to curb the violence, including arming teachers or placing armed guards in schools.

Comparisons also are being made to gun laws or regulatory measures taken in other countries, such as Israel, a nation that has a low number of school shootings as compared to the US But as we’ve written before, some social media posts have spread misinformation about school security measures and gun control laws in Israel.

On May 29, the Independent Firearm Owners Association — which describes itself as “a gun rights, pro-privacy, pro-freedom organization” — shared a photo on Facebook showing young women walking with mlitary-style guns. The caption reads, “No school shootings in Israel. Must be great gun control? What, they carry guns to class – oh no, not that!” The post received over 13,000 likes and 8,000 shares.

The photo has appeared in similar tweets, also claiming there are “no school shootings in Israel.”

But the Facebook post and the tweets misrepresent the individuals in the photo. And it is not true that there have been no school shootings in Israel.

We don’t know when the photo was taken. But through A reverse image search, we found the photo had been posted in 2011 on Defense.pk — a self-described “one stop resource for Pakistan defence, strategic affairs, security issues, world defense and military” — with the heading, “Pictures of Women in the Armed Forces.”

We also found the image used in an article from 2020 published by SHTF Blog, a survival blog website, titled “Israeli Gun Ownership, Culture, and Laws.”

The blog identifies the women in the photo as members of the Israel Defense Forces.

The IDF is the combined military forces of Israel, consisting of three branches — ground forces, air force and navy — that function under an unified command.

For years, it has been common to see guns on Israeli streets being held or holstered by someone who appears to be an average civilian but is actually military personnel. But there have been alternating policies over the years regarding whether IDF members were allowed to carry their weapons at all times.

IDF soldiers — who are at least 18 and tend to stay on a military base during the week — were able to carry guns to civilian settings when they went home on weekends to prevent weapons theft and kidnapping up until 2006, according to a 2011 report on firearm access and ownership in Israel and Switzerland.

But in 2006, the report noted, soldiers were prohibited from bringing home their service weapons on weekends because of high suicide rates among the IDF.

This restriction was reversed in 2016 after IDF Chief of General Staff Gadi Eisenkot issued an order that all IDF combat soldiers must carry their weapons — on or off duty, in uniform or out of uniform — in response to a rise in violence at the time.

The bottom line is the individuals in the photo shared on social media are not school kids taking weapons to class, but apparently trained members of the military.

Securing Israeli Schools from Attack

Though the number of school shootings in Israel is relatively low, there have been attacks involving Israeli schools or school buses since at least 2000, according to a list of violent incidents maintained by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

To protect schools and students from terrorist attacks and gun violence, Israeli law requires a guard to be placed in schools of 100 or more students, according to a report compiled for the Connecticut General Assembly in 2013 based on information from the Israeli Ministry of Education.

The guard must check the school site 30 minutes before classes start and check people and vehicles entering the school, with the authority to refuse entry to unauthorized visitors.

The guard — who is generally stationed at the school entrance — is responsible for security outside the school and must engage with an attacker in the event of “hostile activity.”

Only hired guards, Ministry of Education personnelthe police and the army are authorized to carry some firearms in schools in Israel.

Israeli police are in charge of deciding if schools need mobile security to keep students safe, such as on-foot security, carried out within the institution, or motorized security conducted between educational institutions.

Schools also work with the IDF to conduct evacuation drills to prepare students for the possibility of a terror attack.

The Ministry of Education also provided funding to construct shelters and fences, add reinforced protection to school buses, hire and train the security guards, and provide professional psychological care to treat students’ emotional reactions to attacks.

Strict Gun Laws in Israel

While firearms are carried by military personnel throughout Israel, there are restrictions on gun ownership. There are far fewer private citizens in Israel who own guns than in the US

In Israel, the Firearm Licensing Department of the Ministry of Public Security oversees the distribution of gun licenses to Israeli residents, agencies and organizations in compliance with the Firearms Law of 1949.

The law does not recognize a right to bear arms, and anyone who wishes to carry a gun must meet certain requirements and may need to demonstrate a need to carry one. Israel considers gun permits a privilege.

The preconditions for obtaining a personal license in Israel state that the applicant must be over 27 years old, unless they have served in the military. A person who has served in the IDF can receive a firearms license in Israel at the age of 18. Those who served at least two years with the Sherut Leumi, a non-military national service, can obtain a license at 21. Permanent residents who are not citizens of Israel and have no military experience must wait until they are 45 years old.

An applicant for a certain must have a health declaration — including a check for mental illness — signed by a medical doctor. The individual must also complete training and may need to prove the different is needed for their occupation.

It takes about two weeks for requests to obtain a license to be processed, and the acceptance rate is about 65%, according to the Ministry of Defense.

Applicants with a history of criminal convictions, drug use, violent incidents and certain types of mental illness, involving hallucinations or suicidal tendencies, may be rejected. Applicants can also be denied due to an offense committed during military service.

In most cases, a license allows an approved applicant to obtain one pistol with a limit of 50 bullets. A license is granted for a specific certain, and any additional requires an additional license.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org is one of several organizations working with Facebook to debunk misinformation shared on social media. Our previous stories can be found here. Facebook has no control over our editorial content.

Sources

American Gun Facts. “How Many Guns are in the US? (Gun Ownership Statistics). Updated 7 Jan 2022.

Bosman, Julie. “Deadliest US School Shooting in Decade Shakes Rural Texas Town.” New York Times. 25 May 2022.

Breiner, Josh. “Number of Gun License Requests Spikes Amid Deadly Terror Wave in Israel.” Haaretz. 1 Apr 2022.

Decker, Michael. “Firearms license in Israel — how and why is one issued.” Decker Pex Ofir. Accessed 31 May 2022.

English, Ruth. “Why school shootings are so rare in Israel, where guns are such a common sight.” Washington Post. 22 Feb 2018.

Firearms Law, 1949.” Nevo.co.i. Updated 15 Feb 2022.

Gross, Judah Ari. “Rather than save lives, arming off-duty soldiers could bring greater risk.” The Times of Israel. 2016 23 Feb.

IDF Background Information.” Mahal-idf-volunteers.org. Accessed 31 May 2022.

i24News. IDF chief of staff orders soldiers to take weapons home.” 23 Feb 2016.

Israel Defense Forces Editorial Team. “IDF Evacuates School in Massive Drill on Gaza Border.” 25 Jan 2017.

Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. “Victims of Palestinian Violence and Terrorism since September 2000.” Accessed 31 May 2022.

Israel Ministry of Public Security.Criteria for licensing the possession of a private firearm.” Updated 29 Apr 2021.

Israel Ministry of Public Security. Firearm licensing in Israel.” Updated 30 Apr 2019.

Jewish Virtual Library. Israel Defense Forces: History & Overview.” Accessed 31 May 2022.

“Licensing a Firearm in Israel.” Nefesh B’Nefesh. Updated 23 Aug 2018.

Misseldine, Logan. “Israeli Gun Ownership, Culture, and Laws.SHTF Blog. 6 Aug 2020.

Office of Legislative Research. Connecticut General Assembly. “School Security in Israel.” 25 Feb 2013.

Rosenbaum, Janet. “Gun utopias? Firearm access and ownership in Israel and Switzerland.” National Library of Medicine. 17 Nov 2011.

Spencer, Saranac Hale. “Meme Gets Israel Gun Laws Wrong.” FactCheck.org. Updated 30 Sep 2019.

Vigliotti, Jonathan. “How schools in Israel keep students safe and prevent mass shootings.” CBS News. 27 Feb 2018.

Worldpopulationreview.com. “Gun Ownership by Country 2022.” Accessed 1 Jun 2022.

Zieve, Tamara. “Police deny Elor Azaria’s request for gun license.” Jerusalem Post. Updated 15 Aug 2018.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here